Two September 5 Moments That Changed Miami: A Pioneer Wedding and the Birth of Greater Miami

13 hours ago
4 min read

Before Miami had skyscrapers, traffic jams and beachside hotels, September 5 marked two very different moments in the city's history. Actually, September 5 gives us two snapshots of the city separated by just 49 years.

The first takes us back to 1876, when Miami was still a remote pioneer settlement and a young woman named Rose Wagner was married in a tiny wooden chapel beside her family's home.

The second takes us to 1925, at the height of South Florida's spectacular real estate boom, when Miami officially became Greater Miami through a major annexation that dramatically increased the city's boundaries.

September 5, 1876

A Wedding on the Miami River

In 1876, there was no downtown skyline, no Brickell Avenue and no Ocean Drive. Miami was a small, isolated settlement along the river, surrounded by tropical wilderness.

The Wagner family was one of the area's pioneering families. William and Eveline Wagner had established their home near what was then known as Wagner Creek, in the vicinity of today's Jackson Health complex. Their daughter, Rose Wagner, had grown up in this early Miami community after arriving in the area as a six-year-old child in 1858.

The Wagners were also deeply connected to the religious life of the settlement.

In 1872, Catholic Mass was celebrated at the Wagner home. A few years later, at the request of Bishop Augustine Verot, William Wagner built a small chapel beside the family residence. The simple wooden structure measured approximately 40 by 10 feet and had a wooden cross above it. It became the first house of worship in this pioneer settlement.

And then, on September 5, 1876, the little chapel hosted a wedding.

Rose Wagner married Adam C. Richards, a pioneer who had been associated with the Wagner family and their coontie starch operation. Father Hugan, who had traveled to Miami from Key West, officiated at the ceremony.

For such a small community, it was a big occasion.

Historical accounts describe the wedding as quite a social event. White pioneers attended, as did Native Americans who were living in the region and reportedly watched the proceedings with curiosity.

On September 5, 1876, Rose Wagner married Adam Richards at her family’s homestead in Miami. The ceremony was officiated by Father Hugan of Key West, who traveled to the sparsely populated settlement, later incorporated as the City of Miami, to perform the wedding.

Rose Wagner's story continued long after the wedding

Rose and Adam Richards eventually established their own homestead in what is now the South Miami area. They raised 10 children and became part of the early Larkins community. Their property later contributed land for a public school and a cemetery.

The Richards family's connection to the area can still be traced today. Land associated with their homestead became part of the landscape around present-day Sunset Elementary School and Pinewood Cemetery.

Rose also left something even more valuable for historians: her memories.

In the early 1900s, she wrote a series of reminiscences about her childhood and early life in Miami. Those recollections have become an important source for understanding what the Miami River community was like during the city's earliest years.

William Wagner Homestead, Miami: Built in the mid-1850s by pioneer William Wagner beside Wagner Creek, a tributary of the Miami River later named in his honor. In 1979, Dade Heritage Trust saved the historic homestead and moved it to Lummus Park, where it remains today. Photo courtesy of Ebyabe/CC-BY-SA-3.0

September 5, 1925

Greater Miami Is Created

Now jump ahead 49 years.

Miami had become almost unrecognizable.

The railroad had arrived in 1896. New neighborhoods were spreading outward. Roads, automobiles, hotels and real estate development were transforming South Florida. By the 1920s, Miami was caught up in the Great Florida Land Boom, with developers aggressively promoting new communities and investors speculating on property.

Then came September 1925.

On September 2, voters considered a proposal to expand the City of Miami by annexing surrounding communities and areas, including Coconut Grove, Silver Bluff, Allapattah, Lemon City, Buena Vista and Little River. Three days later, on September 5, 1925, Greater Miami was officially created.

The expansion was enormous. Miami's boundaries grew dramatically, transforming a relatively compact city into a much larger municipality.

But there was controversy, particularly in Coconut Grove.

While the overall vote strongly favored annexation, Coconut Grove voters overwhelmingly opposed it. Historical records show that 180 Coconut Grove voters voted against annexation while only 26 voted in favor. Because Miami's much larger electorate participated in the vote, the overall result nevertheless favored the creation of Greater Miami.

The controversy continued to unfold. Contemporary reporting shows that on September 4, 1925, Coconut Grove residents were already preparing to challenge the proposed annexation. At the same time, Miami was in the midst of its spectacular real estate boom, with rapid development and intense speculation reshaping the city.

Miami was undergoing extraordinary growth during the 1920s land boom. A 1925 map shows the ambitious vision for the expanding city, while period photographs displayed below capture the rapid development taking place around it.